1. Give the novel Mrs. Frisby and the Rats of NIMH a score out of 10. Give reasons for your rating.10/15/2016
31 Comments
Caillou
10/15/2016 11:22:24 pm
My rating for Mrs. Frisby is 8. It would have been 10 but I just did not think they explained stuff that well. For example the rosebush. They explain it well on the inside of it. The thing was they did not explain the outside of it enough. When I saw it in the movie it was nothing like I pictured it to be.
Reply
Hermione
10/17/2016 01:20:49 pm
Caillou I very much agree with but i think they should have gotten a 8 and 1/2 because I think they have explained very well but they should have added more detail and explained what Mr.Fitzgibbon was doing all that time
Reply
BATMAN
10/17/2016 01:21:00 pm
I agree about explaining the visuals more but a rose bush is pretty easy to visualize (in my opinion)
Reply
Molly
10/17/2016 01:23:10 pm
Caillou I agree with you it wasn't very detailed I would also give it and 8 partly an 8 because it wasn't very detailed and didn't explained it as much
Reply
juliet
10/17/2016 01:38:03 pm
to be honest, i do not agree with any of you guys. i think it was pretty detailed, but the book's main focus was the thoughts and strategies the mice came up with. but, that doesn't mean they did not focus on making visuals for us to come up with. i think we have the agree that the at least gave enough information for us to at least create a map of the scenery they were in. besides, i think we all can agree that the movie was very different from the book.
Joker
10/17/2016 01:36:50 pm
I think your rate is accurate because they didnt explain the rosebush and other things
Reply
BATMAN
10/17/2016 01:17:55 pm
I'm giving Mrs. Frisby a score of 8.5 out of 10. I'm giving the book that score because I like how the author used the idea of rat experimenting and made them smarter than the "average rat". I also thought the concept of the book was very interesting because she got to learn more about the rats and Mr. Frisby. I didn't give the story a 10 because I thought the story could have been more interesting and ,focus on some other things instead of the entire story focusing more on moving Mrs. Frisby's house.
Reply
kareem abdul-jabbar
10/19/2016 08:24:11 pm
i agree with u i think the same way they did the rat expieramenting
Reply
oo7
10/17/2016 01:18:16 pm
i well give the book a 7 out of 10. i well give this riot because it was a ok book. some parts were kind of dumb like the rats when they had a kind of lab in a bush. and how a crow can talk. but it was a good book
Reply
Kyrie Irving
10/17/2016 01:18:24 pm
I give Mrs Frisby 8.5 because in the book I can see every detail that they say like they told about what i was always wondering in my mind but In the movie what i remember in the book i didn't see in the book so i give it 8.5 not 10.
Reply
BLUE
10/17/2016 01:19:11 pm
I would Mrs. Frisdy a 10 out of 10 because I loved the topic and idea of the story it was fun reading it
Reply
Molly
10/17/2016 01:21:11 pm
My rating for Mrs. Frisby and the rats of NIMH is an 8. I gave it a 8 because I don't think there wasn't as much as detail as the movie. Yes, the movie was kind of exaggerated but it was really detailed and the book didn't have a lot of detail. If it was as detailed as the movie I would have given it a 10.
Reply
Dorothy
10/17/2016 01:21:17 pm
I give "Mrs. Frisby and the Rats of Nimh" a 9 out of 10 because it addressed many topics and ideas, and had a very creative and and well thought out storyline. The story had all different genres in it, such as, fantasy, science fiction, and mystery. It was a great book!
Reply
KOBE
10/17/2016 01:21:53 pm
I would rate this book a 9 out of 10 because it was interesting but it was confusing at some parts because it went from timothy being sick to the rats of nihm
Reply
REVERSE FLASH
10/17/2016 01:21:59 pm
I would give the book a 6 because I feel like the all the characters in the book were just boring and didn't have distinct personalities example:Jeremy just is a typical guy,he is one of the only flying characters in the book and his is important to the storyline I was expecting more from him, but he did get his job done for the plot.
Reply
Flash
10/17/2016 01:22:47 pm
I would give Mrs.Frisby a 10 out of 10 because i loved the book about the rat in the lab broke out of the lab
Reply
Quick Silver
10/17/2016 01:22:48 pm
I rate the book 8.5 because some of the stuff doesn't to me at all.
Reply
Leonado
10/17/2016 01:24:33 pm
I think it was a 9 because it was interesting to read and experiancing the life of these rats.
Reply
superman
10/17/2016 01:24:52 pm
i would give it 9/10 because it was good and interesting so i say it deserves a 9 and no more cause the rats were cool and they were able to figure out and that was cool
Reply
Toopy
10/17/2016 01:25:44 pm
My rating for Mrs. Frisby is 9 because its a very interesting book and it had a to of action and adventure involved. I rate it 9 out of 10 because it wasn't very detailed, I think it should have been more detailed. y rating for the movie is 3 because it wasn't very exciting or what i had expected it to be. I thought it would be more like the book but the movie was very childish and there wasn't a lot of adventure. The movie also didn't have much detail and the movie wasn't accurate at all.
Reply
Garfield
10/17/2016 01:26:40 pm
My rating for Mrs. Frisby is a 8.5. Overall it was a really good book. It was interesting and I really enjoyed reading it. I actually found the beginning a bit boring but after we started reading it soon got more interesting and fun to read. I would definitely refer this book to other people and encourage them to read Mrs. Frisby. If I could change one thing about the book I'd make Nicodemus tell the story a little faster. In my opinion I just think that too much time was taken up telling the story. I understand it is an important part of the story, but if they left out a few things it would've been more to the point. But otherwise a really good book.
Reply
Steph Curry
10/17/2016 01:28:27 pm
I give Mrs.Frisby and the rats of NIMH a 8 out of 10 because it was an interesting book but the downside is it was very interesting but not always it got boring sometimes and that is not good because it made me not wanna pay attention.
Reply
kareem Abdul-Jabbar
10/17/2016 01:29:05 pm
Im giving Mrs. Frisby a score of 9. This is because the book explained the story of the rats very well and the inside of their house. They could have explained mrs. frisby's house better with more detail. Also because i found something interesting and that is how they did a short story about the rat experimenting and how they escaped.
Reply
Ronaldo
10/17/2016 01:29:11 pm
I would give Mrs.Frisby a 8.5 becaue its a good book but if they had made the book a little longer it would just be grate
Reply
arnold
10/17/2016 01:30:38 pm
I will rate ms frisby a 8.5 because it was good but not the best book
Reply
Barbie
10/17/2016 01:32:17 pm
8/10 , because it wasn't very realistic such as times when the rats created a lab in the rosebush and when Mrs.Frisby and all the other animals could create medicines and drugs and even talk to each other.
Reply
Smaug
10/17/2016 01:38:52 pm
I give Mrs.Frisby 8.5 out of 10.I gave an 8 because in the book they author had written a lot of detail which most of the time gave me a really vision of the setting. also I liked how the book is a perspective of the rats and the mice and not in the perspective of a narrator. I think this book could improve by also having a perspective of Mr.Ages or someone else i think that it would be interesting to read someone elses perspective of this book.
Reply
Captain underpants
10/17/2016 01:39:04 pm
I give the book a 8/10 it is very intresting. What i did not like was that it had no focuse it was all over the place.and was not neatly plotted. It was also way better that the secret of nimh, because it was more real and Mrs frisby was living in a pot instead of a cinder block
Reply
Joker
10/17/2016 01:42:17 pm
I would give the book a 9 because they explained everything good beside the rosebush the bearly described the inside and not even the outside. When i watched the movie i got a better idea of everything
Reply
StrykerTheGamer
10/17/2016 01:46:31 pm
i want to wach the movie for holes
Reply
Margaret Simon
10/19/2016 07:24:31 pm
I would give the novel a 10 out of 10. The book is very precise and also has a science fiction angle which provides appeal for some. As you read on, the adventure gets more and more exciting. From labs to sewers, and from valleys to electricity and motors, the adventure will just amaze you. The sadness of the story and what Mrs. Frisby, a young, widowed mouse, had to go through just adds to the excitement and adventure of the book. The detail and description throughout the book just adds to the book's greatness. Robert C O'Brien is a great writer and I really enjoyed the different aspects of the book. I particularly liked the portion of the book that was focused on the teamwork of the rats.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |